We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
We tested upright vacuum cleaners from Shark, Dyson, Kenmore, and others in order to find the best products for your home
We've tested a wide range of upright vacuums, at different price points and levels of performance, so you can choose the model that suits you the best.
After researching hundreds of upright vacuums, we bought the best 10 to rigorously test side-by-side. We took a look at the top models, making a wide variety of messes on all types of floors to rate and compare cleaning performance. We also looked at convenience and how easily each upright vacuum operates. Additionally, we looked at how convenient and easy to operate each vacuum is, as well as its maneuverability and any other features that differentiate one model from another. Keep reading to see which vacuums performed the best, which are great budget-friendly options, and which are perfect for a specialty job like pet hair pick up or flour on the hardwood floor after baking.
Editor's Note: Our upright vacuum review was updated on December 8, 2023, to include more vacuum comparisons and recommendations in our award section. We also removed a discontinued Hoover model from our lineup.
Superior cleaning performance all-around, easy handling, and a lift-away feature make the Shark Stratos one of the best upright vacuums you can go out and purchase today. Shark has continued to enhance its duo clean technology, and its dual brush roll system cleans dirt and debris from a range of messes across a wide range of surfaces. So whether you're vacuuming on a low-pile carpet, high-pile carpet, or hard floors, you'll finish with beautifully cleaned surfaces. The lift-away feature increases user-friendliness and allows you to clean stairs more easily, reach under furniture, and make difficult-to-reach areas more accessible.
We had very few bones to pick with the Shark Stratos. Only when our testing team made critical side-by-side comparisons did they come up with minor criticisms. The Stratos was narrowly outperformed in carpet cleaning performance by one other Shark model. We think it could stand to make a tiny improvement in its edging ability and could be a little lighter. Still, it's such a phenomenal vacuum that it is hard to dislike anything about it. If the price is just a bit too high, the lighter and more affordable Shark Navigator Lift Away is also a great pick we recommend checking out.
Shark has no real competition outside of itself in the world of upright vacuums, making not just one but a few of the best models available at various price points. We were splitting hairs when it came down to selecting the top model for our upright vacuum review. The Shark Vertex is an exceptional model in our product test lineup. This vacuum floored us with its performance, sweeping almost every other model under the rug. The Vertex made easy work of cleaning up all types of messes, whether on flat carpet, fluffy carpet, or hard floors. It's exceptionally easy to use and is one of the more versatile vacuums thanks to the included attachments and the Lift-Away feature, which allows you to remove the canister.
When it comes to performance, we have zero complaints about the Vertex. The only real drawback is the price, which is undoubtedly higher than some folks might be willing to pay. The slightly larger head and canister size make it great for large carpeted areas, but it lessens the degree of maneuverability and hardwood floor performance. Again, the differences were subtle. If you're willing to fork over the money, the Vertex won't disappoint, as we think the excellent and reliable performance is well worth the investment. If it is outside your price range, the Eureka PowerSpeed is an affordable option for strict budgets.
The Shark Navigator Lift Away is our top recommendation for those who want good performance without entirely emptying their pockets. This easy to use vacuum handles just as well as its premium counterparts and can suction debris with just a few extra passes. The 'Lift Away' function of this model allows it to pull the canister and hose away from the rest of the vacuum and carry it around like you would a handheld vacuum. It also comes with a HEPA filter, which prevents dust and debris from flying out while you vacuum — something you won't always see in a vacuum at this price point. Lastly, it did an ace job at picking up pet hair.
There are some downsides to the Shark Lift Away. Most notably, it does not vacuum hardwood and carpet flooring as well as premium upright models do. As such, it will add a little extra time to your daily chores, but not by that much. Overall, we think this vacuum will suit those who want premium qualities in their vacuum at a reasonable price point. But if you would rather save some time, the Shark Stratos performs well on carpet and hardwood floors alike.
Those on a super tight budget should consider the Eureka PowerSpeed. Overall, this model is a good value, offering decent performance at an attractive price. It is maneuverable, easy to use, and rather good at picking up pet hair. If you have a home full of pets and desire a good dollar-for-dollar value from an affordable investment, this is a great choice.
Of course, budget buys don't offer the premium performance available from significantly more expensive models. The PowerSpeed does a decent job cleaning carpets and an okay job on hard surfaces, but we think it's a good selection for those with very tight budgets. But, if you can swing it, it is worth considering some of our other top recommendations, like the Shark Vertex or the Shark Stratos.
The Eureka is incredibly lightweight - even our smallest testers had no issue lifting this unit.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
Compare Products
We used precisely measured amounts of different debris types to accurately measure each model's ability to clean on short and high pile carpets. Pictured above is the Shark Stratos.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
Why You Should Trust Us
To rate these products, we put them through a series of vacuum cleaning performance tests designed to push each model to its performance limits. We conducted over 20 different tests for each vacuum, which works out to hours upon hours of sucking up pet hair, oatmeal, cereal, flour, and rice from many styles of carpeting and hard flooring.
Our tests are grouped into five weighted rating metrics:
Carpet Cleaning (35% of overall score weighting)
Ease of Use (25% weighting)
Handling (20% weighting)
Hard Surface (10% weighting)
Pet Hair (10% weighting)
Our in-house vacuum testers, Austin Palmer and Jessica Riconscente, have tested the best canister vacuums, stick vacuums, and the top handheld vacuums since 2015. Both have logged many hours, and together bring a combination of industrial technology, heavy machinery knowledge, critical problem solving, and tech analysis skills to our test designs and operations.
We've also consulted with Lindsey Schultz, co-owner of Mighty Tidy Tahoe, a professional cleaning service that cleans nearly 1000 rental homes, residences, and offices annually. Lindsey lent her expertise to our evaluation and testing results, helping our team refine and revise our testing plan and process.
From obstacle courses to piles of debris, all our tested vacuums went through a batter of tough tests to help you find the best.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman
Analysis and Test Results
To discover the right vacuum for you, we split our various assessments into five weighted rating metrics. We evaluated Carpet Cleaning, Ease of Use, Handling, Hard Surface Cleaning, and Pet Hair, and weighted each testing metric relative to its significance on overall performance and expectations from a vacuum.
The Kenmore Elite performed excellently when it came to cleaning carpets.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman
Value
If the premium options are too far out of your price range, consider the high-value Shark Navigator Lift Away. This upright vacuum makes only minor concessions, struggling slightly at cleaning hard floors compared to the top models, but scores very well in every other aspect. It does all this at a reasonably affordable price too. However, if this is still outside your budget, then the Eureka PowerSpeed is your next best option. It definitely can't compete with the cleaning power of more premium models, especially when handling tougher messes. Still, it does quite well considering it is a fraction of the cost of those other models.
Carpet Cleaning
Carpet cleaning accounts for 35% of each upright vacuum's score — the largest of any metric. We used oatmeal, cereal, rice, and flour as our sample debris, spreading out a measured amount on low-pile and high-pile carpet, pressing it in with a floor roller, then running each vacuum over it. We compared the results, counting the number of passes to get the floor visually clean and comparing the amount of debris picked up in a single pass.
The Shark Vertex claimed the top spot overall in our carpet cleaning tests. This vacuum did a phenomenal job in our rice test, completely cleaning up all of the grains from both the flat and fluffy carpet in just two passes. It was a similar story with the dry oatmeal and the Cheerios, with virtually all of the mess removed with just a forward and back pass. The Vertex even impressed us in our flour cleaning test, which is one of the more difficult tests of the process and one that challenges many models. It took a few more passes to completely clean up all of the flour than the rice, oatmeal, or cereal, but it still took significantly fewer passes than almost every other vacuum we tested.
The Shark Stratos followed the Vertex with more excellent carpet cleaning performances. It did exceptionally well at cleaning all of the flour, cereal, and oatmeal debris used in our tests, with the majority of each mess being lifted away in a first pass and only requiring a couple of follow up passes to achieve impressive results. Rice on low-pile carpet required a few more passes at a slightly offset angle to completely clean our test mess, but the Stratos did a great job on high-pile carpet.
The APEX made quick work of our simulated dust test.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman
The Dyson Ball Animal 3 Extra followed behind the Sharks, exhibiting excellent performances on low and high-pile carpet when cleaning rice and oatmeal messes — clearing most of our test material in the first pass and finishing the task with very few follow up passes. As expected, cereal and flour proved to be a bit more challenging on high-pile carpet, although it had no real issues on low-pile carpet.
We were impressed with the performance of the Vertex with all manner of messes.
Credit: Jason Peters
The Shark Navigator Lift-Away Professional followed just behind the pack leaders and did very well at collecting rice. However, it required a few extra passes to catch the residual grains, ultimately not performing as well on fluffier carpets. It also struggled a little with the flour on the flat carpet but did an excellent job on the fluffier carpet. For oats and cereal, a few extra passes were required to get all the debris on the fluffier carpet, but this model finished with a strong overall performance on low-pile carpet.
Chasing the Lift Away Professional in carpet cleaning performance is the non-professional model, the Shark Navigator Lift-Away. This model didn't do quite as well as other higher-end Shark models or the professional model of the same namesake. It took a couple of extra passes to extract lingering grains of rice and repeated similar performances on oatmeal and cereal. The cereal required some finagling to angle the head and avoid displacing Cheerios. Its flour performance was also not as good as any other Shark model, requiring a lot of passes to extract 99%.
The Kenmore struggled slightly with the flour on low-pile carpet.
Credit: Austin Palmer
The Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly performed excellently in the rice collection test, requiring only a couple of passes to clean up everything on both low and high-pile carpets. This vacuum continued its excellent run when it came to oatmeal and cereal. However, it took a few more passes to get the oatmeal satisfactorily out of the fluffy, high-pile carpet. Unfortunately, the performance dropped when it came to flour on low-pile carpet. Though it still managed a good performance cleaning the flour out of the high-pile carpet.
The Dyson Ball Animal 2 collecting flour from carpet.
Credit: Jessica Riconscente
The Eureka PowerSpeed performed just above average when cleaning carpets. The PowerSpeed did a decent job of cleaning up rice, oats, and cereal from both types of carpet, provided that we went slowly. However, move too quickly, and this tends to fling debris every which way — potentially making a larger mess than you started with.
With slower movements and a lower pile carpet, the PowerSpeed was able to handle our Cheerio test quite well. Higher pile carpet was more difficult for it.
Credit: Jason Peters
Ease of Use
We weighted this metric to account for 25% of each model's final score. Our team compared each vacuum cleaner's noise, maximum reach, the ease of cleaning close to edges and under furniture, and how each vacuum handled transitioning between different surfaces.
Many vacuums performed well in this metric, with the Shark Stratos and Shark Vertex both handling surface transitions exceptionally well, with a simple click of the button on the handle. The hard floor option will slow the rotating brush, while the low and high-pile carpet options will vary the suction power.
The Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly also proved to be very user-friendly, performing well against walls and providing a long cord for reaching far and away from an outlet. It is middle of the road when it comes to under-furniture reach, averaging around 8 inches. Lastly, the Pet Friendly adjusts via a knob for easy surface transitions and also has the ability to turn off the brush.
We measured the decibels of each vacuum to see which was the most disruptive.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
The Dyson Ball Animal 3 Extra very closely followed the performance of the Pet Friendly and gives users great edging, surface transition options, and great overall reach, but its under-furniture reach is a little limited.
The Navigator Lift-Away Professional closely trailed the top for models, with an option to turn the rotating brush on or off. Still, it lacks options for different carpet piles or for adjusting the height of the extractor. However, a convenient button located near the top of the vacuum makes it straightforward to turn the brush on or off.
The Shark Vertex easily darted around our traffic cone obstacle course.
Credit: Jessica Riconscente
These vacuums clean very close to corners and right up to the walls of a room. These products also effectively clean under furniture and are able to reach quite far under our simulated sofa. They aren't overly loud, and all have substantial cleaning reach between their hoses and power cords.
The swivel steering makes the CleanView very maneuverable.
Credit: Laura Casner
Handling
Comprising 20% of the total score, this metric encompasses maneuvering each vacuum around common obstacles, cleaning stairs, and the pushing/pulling effort required from each model to clean.
When it comes to handling the Shark Navigator Lift Away and Kenmore FeatherLite did exceptionally well. While the Shark Stratos followed very closely, and the Shark Vertex was just a bit further behind.
The Stratos is a top model when it comes to maneuverability.
Credit: Jessica Riconscente
The Shark Navigator Lift Away and Kenmore FeatherLite were exceptional in handling, although; all of these models have great reach on stairs, maneuver very well, and require minimal pushing and pulling effort.
As a non-swiveling model, the Endura Reach surprised us with its overall handling ability. Although it did not maneuver as well as swiveling models, its light weight made it easier to manipulate, requiring less pushing and pulling effort than many other models. That lower weight, combined with a fairly long hose, made it a great model for handling stairs.
The CleanView Swivel Pet performed about the same for the handling metric as the Endura. While it is a swiveling model and is much more maneuverable, it is a couple of pounds heavier and has a shorter hose length, increasing the required pushing and pulling effort and making it less than ideal for stairs.
The Eureka PowerSpeed is one of the lightest upright vacuums in our test group, making it easy to push or pull across a variety of surfaces, but the lack of swivel steering makes it considerably less agile when cleaning around furniture. Its lighter weight also adds stair cleaning convenience, which you will need with an exceptionally short hose length of four feet.
The Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly was the worst handling model of the bunch, further behind than just average models. If you value a smooth-handling vacuum, you'll want to avoid this model. It's heavier and requires more effort to push, pull, and lug up and down stairs.
Hard Surface Cleaning
Making up 10% of the total score, our hard surface testing was practically identical to our carpet cleaning tests, with hardwood floors swapped for carpet. Once again, we spread oatmeal, flour, cereal, and rice on the floor and vacuumed it up, evaluating each model's performance.
The Shark Stratos outperformed the Shark Vertex on hard surface cleaning tests. Using the hard floor setting on both vacuums, they collected practically all of our rice in a single pass. This pair also did a fantastic job cleaning flour from the hard floor, even sucking it out of the cracks and crevices.
A phenomenal performance on a hard surface from the Stratos.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
The dual brush system, integrated into both models, also dusted and polished hardwood floors, whereas lesser models left behind fine films and no sheen.
Impressive results, yet again, from the Vertex.
Credit: Jason Peters
This pair of vacuums carried their excellent performance over to our cereal and oatmeal tests, delivering the best results after only a single pass.
The Shark Stratos effortlessly sucked up all the rice in our hardwood floor tests.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
Both the Shark Navigator Lift-Away Professional and the Shark Navigator Lift Away performed well, with similar above-average performance cleaning rice, oatmeal, and cereal, but both also struggled to clean flour. Disappointingly, even after a dozen passes, neither model could completely clean flour from hardwood flooring.
The Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly did an average job across the entire metric. The remaining models in our product test group did a poor job, frequently causing a bigger mess rather than providing any helpful cleaning aid.
The Dyson Ball Animal 3 Extra also finished our hard surface test with an above-average score, doing an excellent job cleaning flour, an average job handling rice and oatmeal messes, but was unable to clean cereal.
Plowing is a common occurrence on hard surfaces - the Kenmore was no exception.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
Pet Hair
Our pet hair metric was responsible for the remaining 10% of each final score. We spread five grams of pet hair on a high-pile carpet, then pressed it in with a roller. We ran each vacuum over it, calculating the percentage of hair collected to determine final scores.
The majority of the models we tested received top marks when it came to cleaning up after shed pet hair, collecting 90% or more of the pet hair pressed into a carpet.
The Vertex had no issues with pet hair, easily picking up almost every bit of it.
Credit: Jason Peters
The Shark Vertex, Shark Stratos, Shark Navigator Lift-Away, Dyson Ball Animal 3 Extra, Shark Navigator Lift-Away Professional, Eureka PowerSpeed, and the Bissell CleanView Swivel Pet all did exceptionally well, collecting the vast majority of the hair, over 95%, in our tests.
The remaining models, the Dirt Devil Endura Reach and Kenmore Elite Pet Friendly, managed to remove more than 90% of pet hair but less than 95%.
One of our pet hair donors overcame his paralyzing fear of vacuums long enough to pose for a photo, mainly motivated by plenty of treats.
Credit: Jenna Ammerman
Conclusion
We hope that this review has helped you narrow down your options and guided you toward selecting the best upright vacuum cleaner for your needs. Whether you are looking for a top-tier model that can handle heavy-duty messes, has exceptional maneuverability, is lightweight, or you just need a budget-friendly option that completes everyday cleaning.
—
Jessica Riconscente, Austin Palmer, David Wise, and Benjamin Hickok
